Still No Answers
What Happened to Dinari McAlmont?
A family vacation, an official drowning ruling, and allegations of a confrontation that have never been publicly resolved
By City Chic Island Kick
Case status: Bahamian authorities reported that Dinari died by drowning and initially said foul play was not suspected. His family disputes that conclusion and continues to allege that he was assaulted before his death. No criminal charge, publicly released surveillance video or final public coroner’s determination was located during this update.
Editorial and legal note: This article distinguishes official findings from family allegations, advocacy claims and online speculation. No person or organization discussed in this report has been found criminally responsible for Dinari McAlmont’s death.
Dinari McAlmont arrived in The Bahamas with his mother and father on Friday, April 4, 2025. The 23-year-old Guyanese-American from Bowie, Maryland, was supposed to be enjoying a short family vacation at Atlantis Paradise Island.
Less than 24 hours after the family checked into The Reef at Atlantis, Dinari was found unresponsive on a Paradise Island beach. Bahamian authorities eventually announced that a post-mortem examination determined that he had drowned.
His parents have never accepted that the word drowning, by itself, fully explains what happened to their son.
“We deserve answers, and we need justice for Dinari.”
— Michelle Bacchus-McAlmont, Dinari’s mother
The last known hours of Dinari’s life
There are differences between some of the early timelines and the more detailed information released later.
An April 2025 family statement said Dinari went for a walk after dinner and was last seen at approximately 8:30 p.m. Other reports placed the time closer to 8:45 p.m.
Correspondence later shared with the Caribbean Guyana Institute for Democracy gave a more precise time. According to that account, Dinari texted his mother at 10:14 p.m. to say that he was going to get something to eat. His mother said that was the final message she received from him.
At approximately 2 a.m. on April 5, according to the later correspondence, Dinari’s family received a call from Paradise Island police. They were reportedly told that Dinari had been involved in an “incident” at one of the resort’s restaurants.
The allegation presented to his parents was that Dinari had spat at members of staff after being denied access to a restricted area. His mother described that behaviour as completely out of character for her son.
When his parents went searching for him, they were allegedly told by resort security that Dinari had run out of the building. His cellphone location sharing had also stopped working.
These details immediately created a critical question: Why was Dinari reportedly running, and what happened immediately before he left the building?
His mother believed the photograph showed an assault
Dinari’s mother, Michelle Bacchus-McAlmont, is a registered nurse. She said she was initially shown a photograph of her son rather than being allowed to identify him by viewing his body directly.
She described seeing facial injuries, frothy fluid around his mouth and sand throughout his hair. To her, the condition of her son’s face appeared consistent with someone who had been attacked.
“When I looked at the photo they showed me, my son was beaten.”
She also questioned why Dinari would have voluntarily gone to the beach during the night. According to his mother, he did not enjoy beaches and had avoided going onto the beach during another recent Caribbean vacation.
The family was eventually permitted a limited viewing of Dinari’s remains on April 7. They said the visible bruising and sand left them with more questions rather than providing reassurance.
His father, Desmond McAlmont, also complained about the limited information the family was receiving.
“It’s been days, and we still don’t have any clear answers.”
What Bahamian police officially concluded
The Royal Bahamas Police Force identified Dinari publicly and announced that a post-mortem examination found that he died as a result of drowning.
Police also said foul play was not suspected “at this time,” noted that forensic toxicology results were still pending, and said the matter would be forwarded to His Majesty’s Coroner.
Commissioner of Police Shanta Knowles later said the police force stood by the findings of the Bahamian pathologist while the investigation continued. She said the coroner would ultimately make the final determination.
A finding of drowning identifies the immediate physiological cause of death. However, it does not automatically answer every question about how a person entered the water, what occurred beforehand or whether injuries were received before the drowning.
Those surrounding circumstances are at the centre of the McAlmont family’s dispute.
What the later autopsy and toxicology reports revealed
The family reportedly received the Bahamian autopsy and toxicology documents on September 17, 2025.
According to reporting by The Tribune, the documents continued to list drowning as the cause of death. The medical findings reportedly included changes associated with immersion, frothy fluid in the airways and heavy, congested lungs.
The reports also documented numerous recent abrasions and injuries on Dinari’s face, hips, knees, hands, arms and legs.
Toxicology reportedly detected ethanol, methanol and an active marijuana compound along with an inactive metabolite. Public reporting did not provide the concentrations or a medical interpretation showing whether any of those substances caused or contributed to his death.
For the family, the number and location of the abrasions intensified concerns that Dinari may have been involved in a struggle or may have been attempting to defend himself.
The documents also reportedly contained discrepancies involving Dinari’s recorded weight and descriptions of the clothing and footwear found on him.
Important distinction
Abrasions can occur in different ways and do not, by themselves, prove homicide. However, unexplained injuries should be considered alongside surveillance footage, witness accounts, the location of the body and the events preceding the death.
The suspicion that circulated locally
When the case first became public, much of the online discussion in The Bahamas focused on the reported restaurant incident.
The theory circulating was that the alleged spitting encounter may have resulted in Dinari being confronted, chased or assaulted before he ended up outside the resort.
At that time, this was social-media speculation—not verified evidence. No identified local eyewitness publicly provided a complete, independently confirmed account of Dinari’s movements.
However, a later development caused that early theory to receive renewed attention.
The allegation involving surveillance footage
In October 2025, the Caribbean Guyana Institute for Democracy called upon Prime Minister Philip “Brave” Davis to order a full and independent investigation into Dinari’s death.
CGID President Rickford Burke said information supplied by Dinari’s mother alleged that Dinari had been involved in a confrontation inside the resort.
Most significantly, Burke claimed that surveillance footage captured Atlantis’ chief of security assaulting Dinari outside a restroom, causing Dinari to flee from the area.
This is a serious allegation, but it must be treated carefully. The footage has not been released publicly, and the claim has not been independently verified in court or confirmed in a public statement from police or Atlantis.
It nevertheless raises a direct question that authorities and the resort could answer: What exactly does the complete surveillance footage show?
The dry wallet and missing cash
Dinari’s mother said the wallet returned to the family was dry even though authorities said he had drowned. She also claimed money was missing from it.
A dry wallet does not independently establish where Dinari died. The wallet could have been separated from him before he entered the water, recovered elsewhere or protected by the way it was stored.
It is still a potentially important piece of evidence because it raises additional questions:
- Where was the wallet recovered?
- Was it found on Dinari’s body or somewhere else?
- Was its condition documented when collected?
- Was the missing cash reported and investigated?
The strongest remaining leads
Despite the passage of time, several areas of evidence could provide a clearer account of Dinari’s final hours.
Footage from the restaurant, restroom corridors, casino, exits, hotel grounds, and routes leading toward the beach could establish whether Dinari was alone, being followed or involved in a physical confrontation.
Written reports should identify the employees involved, what Dinari was accused of doing, whether force was used, and why police were contacted.
Anyone who saw Dinari inside the restaurant, near the restroom, leaving the building or travelling toward the beach could help reconstruct the missing hours.
Phone records, messages, GPS data, and the point at which location sharing stopped could help identify his route and whether his phone was intentionally turned off, damaged or separated from him.
Investigators should clarify what Dinari was wearing when last recorded on camera, what was found with his body and why the descriptions reportedly differed.
The family announced plans for an independent examination. A complete comparison of both examinations, along with a final coroner’s finding, would help address conflicting interpretations of the injuries.
What has not been publicly answered
- Who last saw Dinari alive?
- What prompted the alleged restaurant confrontation?
- Was Dinari physically restrained, struck or pursued?
- Why did his phone’s location-sharing feature become inactive?
- How did he travel from the resort building to the area where he was found?
- Where exactly were his wallet and cellphone recovered?
- Why were his wallet, clothing, and footwear reportedly inconsistent with the official account?
- Did investigators identify how each of the documented recent abrasions occurred?
- Was the alleged security assault captured on video?
- What became of the matter after it was forwarded to the coroner?
The October 2025 demand for an independent investigation
The Caribbean Guyana Institute for Democracy sent its appeal to the Bahamian prime minister and copied several senior American officials.
The organization requested a “proper, fair, full, comprehensive and rigorous investigation” and urged authorities to have all available evidence examined before determining whether Dinari’s death was accidental or a homicide.
The family went further, accusing resort security and the Royal Bahamas Police Force of potentially concealing the true circumstances of Dinari’s death.
Those accusations have not been proven. However, the easiest way to challenge public suspicion would be through transparency: a complete timeline, a clear explanation of the injuries, preservation and review of all video, and a publicly communicated final outcome from the coroner.
Where the case stands now
As of August 5, 2026, the most recent substantial public development located was the October 2025 request for an independent investigation.
No credible public announcement was located confirming that criminal charges were filed, that the alleged surveillance video was released, that the coroner issued a final public ruling or that an independent investigation ordered by the government had been completed.
The official position therefore remains that Dinari drowned. His family’s position remains that something happened to him before he entered the water and that the full story has not been told.
A drowning ruling should not end the questions
Dinari’s family is not disputing that water may have caused his death. They are asking what happened before he reached the water, why he had numerous recent injuries, why he was reportedly running from the building and what the resort’s cameras recorded. Until those questions receive clear, documented answers, this will remain more than a tragic drowning in the eyes of his family.
Sources and further reading
Royal Bahamas Police Force — Official death-investigation update
Eyewitness News Bahamas — Family appeal for information
FOX 5 DC — Police ruling and interview with Dinari’s mother
The Tribune — Family requests an independent autopsy
The Tribune — Police commissioner stands by pathologist’s finding
The Tribune — CGID demands investigation and details later findings
Join the Conversation
Your perspective matters—share your thoughts and connect with the City Chic community.