As the investigation into Nolan Xavier Wells' death continues, something increasingly noticeable has happened among the people whose names became associated with that July 4 trip to Horn Island.
They are not all moving together.
Different friends—and in some cases their parents—appear to be taking different approaches, retaining separate attorneys and responding publicly in different ways. There is nothing inherently unusual or improper about that. Each person has the right to obtain his own attorney and decide whether or not to speak publicly. But one particular group has now become impossible to miss:
Warren Hudson. Jax Pitalo. Morgan Seymour.
The three are being represented together by Mississippi attorney J. Tyler Cox, with prominent attorney Edward Andrew Paltzik joining their legal effort. Paltzik has represented Donald Trump in high-profile media disputes and has extensive experience in defamation litigation.
And Paltzik isn't being cautious about where he stands.
In a joint statement with Cox, the attorneys described Warren, Jax and Morgan as “three completely innocent young men” and said they had “nothing whatsoever to do with” Nolan's death.
That is an extraordinarily firm public defense.
The three have now appeared together with Officer Brandon Tatum, their attorneys are conducting their own investigation, Warren and Jax recently returned to Horn Island with counsel, and a GiveSendGo campaign created by Warren's father is raising money specifically around the legal interests of Warren, Jax and Morgan.
As of the latest screenshot reviewed by City Chic Island Kick, that campaign had raised $170,155 toward a $200,000 goal.
The photograph promoting the fundraiser features the same three young men.
Again:
Warren. Jax. Morgan.
And that's where another question becomes difficult to ignore.
Where is Wyatt?
This is not an accusation against Wyatt Pyron.
There could be an entirely reasonable explanation. Wyatt may have separate counsel. An attorney may have advised him not to participate in interviews. He may have chosen not to join the fundraiser or this particular legal strategy. Or there may be circumstances the public simply doesn't know.
But as the public defense of Warren, Jax and Morgan becomes increasingly organized, Wyatt's absence becomes increasingly noticeable.
Especially because Wyatt is not a peripheral name in the story.
One of the earliest accounts circulating after Nolan disappeared came from a message attributed to Warren Hudson's mother.
In that message, she claimed that Wyatt repeatedly asked Nolan to get onto a boat when it was time to leave, but that Nolan allegedly insisted on remaining behind with a girl whose boat was parked nearby.
That message went even further, claiming other people heard Wyatt asking Nolan several times to board.
Those statements have not been independently established as law-enforcement findings. They represent an early account of what Warren's mother said she had been told.
But if that account is accurate, it potentially places Wyatt in one of the most important alleged conversations of Nolan's final known hours.
Which makes Wyatt's own account important.
What exactly did Nolan say to Wyatt?
What time did that conversation happen?
Who heard it?
Where exactly were they standing?
Which boat did Wyatt subsequently leave on?
Those questions become particularly important because the timeline itself remains contested.
Now Their Attorney Says Nolan Was Seen Around 5:50 P.M.
Paltzik has now publicly claimed that his team's investigation located two witnesses who knew Nolan and say they saw him at approximately 5:50 p.m. on Horn Island.
Paltzik maintains there is no reasonable possibility that those witnesses mistook Nolan for someone else and says their account can be corroborated through additional evidence and eyewitnesses.
If independently verified, a reliable sighting around 5:50 p.m. could become extremely important because the Triton's departure has been placed at approximately 4:31 p.m.
But there is an important distinction:
This is currently a claim coming from attorneys representing Warren, Jax, and Morgan—not an announced change to the official law-enforcement timeline.
Until investigators authenticate and adopt that evidence, City Chic Island Kick will continue treating the alleged 5:50 sighting as a significant claim rather than an established fact.
Then There Are the Boats and Sea Tow
There is another reason I continue coming back to Wyatt.
The marine records surrounding the boats and the Sea Tow incident contain family connections that deserve careful attention.
Names associated with Bart's family and Wyatt's family appear within the records we have been reviewing concerning the vessels/towing events surrounding Horn Island.
That does not establish wrongdoing by Bart, Wyatt or their relatives.
But when determining who was aboard which vessel, who left Horn Island when, which boat experienced mechanical problems, and which vessel required assistance, those records matter.
And they should ultimately be reconciled with the firsthand accounts.
Everyone Seems to Have a Lane — Except Wyatt
Bart has pursued his own legal response and has had separate representation in connection with accusations made publicly about him.
Warren, Jax and Morgan now have a very visible joint legal and public-relations strategy.
Their attorneys aren't merely saying there isn't enough evidence against their clients.
They are affirmatively vouching for them.
They are calling them completely innocent.
They are conducting their own investigation.
They are identifying witnesses they say establish Nolan was alive after their clients left.
They are warning people who continue making allegedly false accusations that they could face litigation.
And Warren, Jax and Morgan themselves are now speaking publicly together.
Which makes it fair to ask:
Where does Wyatt fit into all of this?
Silence is not evidence of guilt.
Choosing not to appear publicly is not suspicious by itself.
Having separate—or no publicly identified—representation does not establish wrongdoing.
But when one person's alleged interaction with Nolan may be central to the final departure timeline, it is reasonable to want that person's account documented directly rather than continually hearing it through other people.
Certain friends and their families appear to have formed their own legal lanes, and that is completely understandable. But Warren, Jax and Morgan have now become such a clearly defined group—with attorneys, a fundraiser, media appearances and lawyers publicly staking their reputations on those three men's innocence—that it naturally highlights the people who aren't included.
And Wyatt stands out because of the role he was alleged to have played in trying to get Nolan onto the boat.
Maybe there is a perfectly ordinary explanation. But until Wyatt's own account is publicly documented—or investigators establish the timeline through independent evidence—I think asking “Where is Wyatt in all of this?” is not only fair.
It's relevant.
Join the Conversation
Your perspective matters—share your thoughts and connect with the City Chic community.